Comments on: “I Know Who Killed Me” Reviews http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/ Lohan Groupie - News, rumors, photos and juice on Lindsay Lohan Sat, 21 Nov 2009 18:37:10 -0500 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.4 hourly 1 By: jorge mathis http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-7851 jorge mathis Fri, 21 Sep 2007 20:23:54 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-7851 Lindsay is a great actress and to me is gorgeous. lLots of people are just jelous and read the papper to much which THEY WILL WRITE ANYTHING TO SELL A PAPPER everybody should just leave her alone she became sussesful on her own not like paris hilton she got all money and fame because of her last name HILTON. Lindsay is a great actress and to me is gorgeous.
lLots of people are just jelous and read the papper to much which THEY WILL WRITE ANYTHING TO SELL A PAPPER everybody should just leave her alone she became sussesful on her own not like paris hilton she got all money and fame because of her last name HILTON.

]]> By: E http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-7402 E Wed, 08 Aug 2007 20:14:24 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-7402 ok whoever didnt see this movie dont continue reading this comment because its goin to be a spoiler.. i have a few questions about the movie that i dont understand... how did dakota know the killer was wearin blue gloves if it was just happenin by itself? n wat was the big secret about the father?? how didnt the mom know she had two kids?? n how was there a tape of just 1 baby ???? pleaseee answer if u saw this movie ok whoever didnt see this movie dont continue reading this comment because its goin to be a spoiler..

i have a few questions about the movie that i dont understand…

how did dakota know the killer was wearin blue gloves if it was just happenin by itself?

n wat was the big secret about the father?? how didnt the mom know she had two kids?? n how was there a tape of just 1 baby ????

pleaseee answer if u saw this movie

]]> By: Larry R http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-6247 Larry R Sun, 05 Aug 2007 08:16:38 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-6247 I will add another comment here, In a REALLY HIGH PROFILE disapearence, like a kidnapping, or abduction for serial killer reasons, the FBI, when THEY get involved, go through the victims personal area, looking for ANY clues, and take Finger Prints, off any thing they can!! in case they can use them to Identify someone, or the missing if found, alive or not. It is a matter of Forensic Policy, and was over looked on this movie. Now if this is all playing out in Aubrey's mind, not in real life, then why have the FBI at all ?? in the case of seriously drugged up people you can't even get lucid real coherant thoughts and sentances out of them, so neither would you from Aubrey. so another point of not making sense, murky directing. murky plot. too too many elements missing, reminds me of a chaotic " Clockwork Orange" with a very bad twist. AND as to Stigmata, that is the subject of MUCH religous debate in the Catholic Church, as it seems to stem from supernatural forces, and seems to have some real bearing on today's world, a sort of ' Yes we're still here ' from the forces of the other world, leaking over into our world. But not something that 'Dakota' Un trained could figure out in the 4 days or so she had to get it. Takes years of study to understand the real ramifactions of the subject, or at least months, and certainly not days, so if that was just " Fantasy " in Aubrey's mind, then the plot of the movie is even murkier, So if he the director IS going for murkey, he succeded. Which in my opinion makes it completely unclear what his motivation was in the shoot, not brillian, but just chaotic, like a child playing with VERY expensive molecule bloocks, to see what the outcome could be. NOT good entertainment. But then again, I don't go to see any of the Freddy movies, or Jason Movies, don't really care for the Predator movies either, no Jason Does Freddy here in this hosehold, or " The Serial Killer that Ate Sheboigan " , not interested in those movies, not in my opinion good entertainment. But You go watch it if you like that sort of thing. I merely post that I don't like the unresolved murky motives of the film director, or what he was really trying to portray, or why when it looked like it was going to be this kind of film, that the Studio Execs didn't rein him in a little....Love You Always Lindsay Lohan, God Bless You Always, from ME Larry T Robinson OR Tn I will add another comment here, In a REALLY HIGH PROFILE disapearence, like a kidnapping, or abduction for serial killer reasons, the FBI, when THEY get involved, go through the victims personal area, looking for ANY clues, and take Finger Prints, off any thing they can!! in case they can use them to Identify someone, or the missing if found, alive or not. It is a matter of Forensic Policy, and was over looked on this movie. Now if this is all playing out in Aubrey’s mind, not in real life, then why have the FBI at all ?? in the case of seriously drugged up people you can’t even get lucid real coherant thoughts and sentances out of them, so neither would you from Aubrey. so another point of not making sense, murky directing. murky plot. too too many elements missing, reminds me of a chaotic ” Clockwork Orange” with a very bad twist. AND as to Stigmata, that is the subject of MUCH religous debate in the Catholic Church, as it seems to stem from supernatural forces, and seems to have some real bearing on today’s world, a sort of ‘ Yes we’re still here ‘ from the forces of the other world, leaking over into our world. But not something that ‘Dakota’ Un trained could figure out in the 4 days or so she had to get it. Takes years of study to understand the real ramifactions of the subject, or at least months, and certainly not days, so if that was just ” Fantasy ” in Aubrey’s mind, then the plot of the movie is even murkier, So if he the director IS going for murkey, he succeded. Which in my opinion makes it completely unclear what his motivation was in the shoot, not brillian, but just chaotic, like a child playing with VERY expensive molecule bloocks, to see what the outcome could be. NOT good entertainment. But then again, I don’t go to see any of the Freddy movies, or Jason Movies, don’t really care for the Predator movies either, no Jason Does Freddy here in this hosehold, or ” The Serial Killer that Ate Sheboigan ” , not interested in those movies, not in my opinion good entertainment. But You go watch it if you like that sort of thing. I merely post that I don’t like the unresolved murky motives of the film director, or what he was really trying to portray, or why when it looked like it was going to be this kind of film, that the Studio Execs didn’t rein him in a little….Love You Always Lindsay Lohan, God Bless You Always, from ME Larry T Robinson OR Tn

]]> By: Rachel Rule:dave must visit LG.com often http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-6709 Rachel Rule:dave must visit LG.com often Fri, 03 Aug 2007 08:48:00 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-6709 larry...i saw your comment earlier about the cops taking her fingerprints to establish either the same person or twins.you only get fingerprinted when you join the service,get a gov't job requiring a security clearance,or get arrested.aubrey would not have had fingerprints on file,as she didn't meet the above criteria;nice try,though.also,the cops had a perfect dna match.twins have 70-90% matching dna,but still have striking differences,so aubrey was one character all along,but with seperate personalities brought on by trauma and her writers active imagination.this movie hinted at all sorts of possibilties,but,in the end,considering this genre,this one is the only one that makes sense.now,before you get all bent out of shape on me,i have to say that i really wanted to see twin sisters(even as an adult,i still love the Parent Trap)but with that said,the sisters would have had to show up the next day,a reunion with their mom,a funeral,etc,and that would have been a problem for this type of film.name me one horror movie that had a happy ending?!they don't,so i went into this with that expectation,but it turned out great in that the piano teacher didn't win over aubreys mind and soul.in her mind,aubrey had wasted the serial killer,and found her other half,so to speak.she had won in that he didn't get to punish her(the cops and profiler had conjectured that the killer wanted to punish the victims)and couldn't get to her mentally,since aubrey had retreated inside herself,sending out her alter-ego,dakota,to find out the killers identity.if you paid attention to the coroner report early on,it said the killers m.o. was to give the victim,'a near-lethal amphetamene dose to keep her aware...',that telling me the victims died.aubrey wasn't dying just from her missing limbs,she was slipping away from too many pills forced on her by the killer. while i would loved to have seen this killer wasted or brought to justice,that is not how this genre works,and the killer stays around for round two,duh. i will agree that it is hard to watch Lindsay in pain,but she IS an actress,an outstanding actress,and should not be limited in her genres and roles,because we have some chauvinistic instinct to see her in a good light.i would love to see her in some risky roles,bad girl roles,characters where we see multiple sides,where you are not too sure who she is.THIS YOUNG WOMAN CAN ACT and i say give her the chance,after all,the iconic actresses of old hollywood were highly versatile and portrayed many types of characters,good,bad,and that gray area of humanity.Lindsay is a fantastic actress,and i hope she takes on more roles like this.one more thing,Lindsay acts with her eyes,in addition to all her other mannerisms,and that is clearly evident in this film.it's why she appears so alive on camera.there are very few actors today that convey emotion so tellingly with their eyes,and miss Lohan is tops in my book.that is all.peace larry…i saw your comment earlier about the cops taking her fingerprints to establish either the same person or twins.you only get fingerprinted when you join the service,get a gov’t job requiring a security clearance,or get arrested.aubrey would not have had fingerprints on file,as she didn’t meet the above criteria;nice try,though.also,the cops had a perfect dna match.twins have 70-90% matching dna,but still have striking differences,so aubrey was one character all along,but with seperate personalities brought on by trauma and her writers active imagination.this movie hinted at all sorts of possibilties,but,in the end,considering this genre,this one is the only one that makes sense.now,before you get all bent out of shape on me,i have to say that i really wanted to see twin sisters(even as an adult,i still love the Parent Trap)but with that said,the sisters would have had to show up the next day,a reunion with their mom,a funeral,etc,and that would have been a problem for this type of film.name me one horror movie that had a happy ending?!they don’t,so i went into this with that expectation,but it turned out great in that the piano teacher didn’t win over aubreys mind and soul.in her mind,aubrey had wasted the serial killer,and found her other half,so to speak.she had won in that he didn’t get to punish her(the cops and profiler had conjectured that the killer wanted to punish the victims)and couldn’t get to her mentally,since aubrey had retreated inside herself,sending out her alter-ego,dakota,to find out the killers identity.if you paid attention to the coroner report early on,it said the killers m.o. was to give the victim,’a near-lethal amphetamene dose to keep her aware…’,that telling me the victims died.aubrey wasn’t dying just from her missing limbs,she was slipping away from too many pills forced on her by the killer. while i would loved to have seen this killer wasted or brought to justice,that is not how this genre works,and the killer stays around for round two,duh. i will agree that it is hard to watch Lindsay in pain,but she IS an actress,an outstanding actress,and should not be limited in her genres and roles,because we have some chauvinistic instinct to see her in a good light.i would love to see her in some risky roles,bad girl roles,characters where we see multiple sides,where you are not too sure who she is.THIS YOUNG WOMAN CAN ACT and i say give her the chance,after all,the iconic actresses of old hollywood were highly versatile and portrayed many types of characters,good,bad,and that gray area of humanity.Lindsay is a fantastic actress,and i hope she takes on more roles like this.one more thing,Lindsay acts with her eyes,in addition to all her other mannerisms,and that is clearly evident in this film.it’s why she appears so alive on camera.there are very few actors today that convey emotion so tellingly with their eyes,and miss Lohan is tops in my book.that is all.peace

]]> By: Rachel Rule:dave must visit LG.com often http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-6705 Rachel Rule:dave must visit LG.com often Fri, 03 Aug 2007 07:59:02 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-6705 i wish i could tell Lindsay,personally,that i am greatly impressed by her acting range,and that i really loved this movie,not just for its cerebral plot,but that her outstanding performance really got to me,both entertaining and emotionally.i really cared about this character and her conflicted soul,particularly in this harrowing ordeal.i accepted the ending as it is a film of the horror/suspense genre,a type of cinema not known for happy endings,but i am content as the personalities did have closure,a reunion of sorts.i will definitely see this movie a fourth time,and will get it on dvd,hopefully a directors cut with the deleted scenes.bravo,miss Lohan,bravo,for an intense performance and a film that i think about,long after i leave the theater.if you people have not seen this movie,please go see it-do not let the haters and agenda-based 'critics' deprive you of a great theater experience.please get well,Lindsay,and we will see you on the other side,hopefully larger-than-life on the silver screen,up where you belong.love always,a huge fan and friend.peace i wish i could tell Lindsay,personally,that i am greatly impressed by her acting range,and that i really loved this movie,not just for its cerebral plot,but that her outstanding performance really got to me,both entertaining and emotionally.i really cared about this character and her conflicted soul,particularly in this harrowing ordeal.i accepted the ending as it is a film of the horror/suspense genre,a type of cinema not known for happy endings,but i am content as the personalities did have closure,a reunion of sorts.i will definitely see this movie a fourth time,and will get it on dvd,hopefully a directors cut with the deleted scenes.bravo,miss Lohan,bravo,for an intense performance and a film that i think about,long after i leave the theater.if you people have not seen this movie,please go see it-do not let the haters and agenda-based ‘critics’ deprive you of a great theater experience.please get well,Lindsay,and we will see you on the other side,hopefully larger-than-life on the silver screen,up where you belong.love always,a huge fan and friend.peace

]]> By: Larry R http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-6685 Larry R Fri, 03 Aug 2007 07:49:44 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-6685 Dan IF your synopsis is correct, then I Know Who Killed Me is a TERRIBLE film, because it is an anti-hero killer gets away with it hollywood propaganda the good guy doesn't always win movie, and those in my opinion ARE NEVER good entertainment !! I HATE movies where the serial killer gets away with it. Disgusting!! Why do you think we have so many Serial Killers out there now, because Society is so aloof from itself, that they can prey on the unsuspecting and hapless. I HAAAAATE that. That is why so many serial killers are caught only after their Nth. victim, because the trail of clues finally catches up with them. So if your theory is correct, then I HATE this movie not just don't like it, hopefully you are wrong, the Piano teacher was just nuts, and the movie ends with so many loose ends for room like a sequal, maybe. If Aubrey actually dies at the end, why not just say so, why have them both together laying on the ground, breathing, wouldn't the movie fade out to black as they took their last breath ?? Your logic seems to be lacking, or else the director could not create a closed end movie. which would be bad directing on his part. I am sticking with my theory of BAD SCIENCE, they needed a better Science Consultant on this one. would have re-aranged the plot a little, made it more believable. Still too hard to watch her get hurt in ANY way, even make believe. I Love Her too much for that. "I" Love You Always Lindsay Lohan, God Bless You Always, from ME Larry T Robinson. Oh yes and another thing, I haven't seen her fellow Actors promoting the movie in Her Absence, WHY NOT!! She did not make that movie all by Her SELF !! Why are THEY not stepping UP and helping to Promote the MOVIE !!!! Dan IF your synopsis is correct, then I Know Who Killed Me is a TERRIBLE film, because it is an anti-hero killer gets away with it hollywood propaganda the good guy doesn’t always win movie, and those in my opinion ARE NEVER good entertainment !! I HATE movies where the serial killer gets away with it. Disgusting!! Why do you think we have so many Serial Killers out there now, because Society is so aloof from itself, that they can prey on the unsuspecting and hapless. I HAAAAATE that. That is why so many serial killers are caught only after their Nth. victim, because the trail of clues finally catches up with them. So if your theory is correct, then I HATE this movie not just don’t like it, hopefully you are wrong, the Piano teacher was just nuts, and the movie ends with so many loose ends for room like a sequal, maybe. If Aubrey actually dies at the end, why not just say so, why have them both together laying on the ground, breathing, wouldn’t the movie fade out to black as they took their last breath ?? Your logic seems to be lacking, or else the director could not create a closed end movie. which would be bad directing on his part. I am sticking with my theory of BAD SCIENCE, they needed a better Science Consultant on this one. would have re-aranged the plot a little, made it more believable. Still too hard to watch her get hurt in ANY way, even make believe. I Love Her too much for that. “I” Love You Always Lindsay Lohan, God Bless You Always, from ME Larry T Robinson. Oh yes and another thing, I haven’t seen her fellow Actors promoting the movie in Her Absence, WHY NOT!! She did not make that movie all by Her SELF !! Why are THEY not stepping UP and helping to Promote the MOVIE !!!!

]]> By: Rachel Rule:dave must visit LG.com often http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-6730 Rachel Rule:dave must visit LG.com often Fri, 03 Aug 2007 07:34:11 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-6730 cobaltduck, an observation on my part;when dakota sleeps with aubreys boyfriend,jerrod,it is really aubrey wanting to have sex,or lose her virginity,before she passes on.aubrey and jerrod were not having sex in their relationship,as she was either a virgin,or not ready for sex in their dating.although aubrey is subtle in her flirting and sexiness,the film does not give any hint if she is a virgin or just cautious about sex.i believe that since aubrey is rather low-key and prim with regards to sex,dakota is a her wild side-an overtly sexual and dominant personality.this movie is full of pyschological details and hidden meanings and really makes you think.you have to see it more than once.i have seen it three times now,and i can say it was money well spent.also,i have to say that Lindsay did a remarkable job in establishing the two characters as entirely seperate personalities,from the physical to the behavioral.she truly is a great actress and compelling onscreen.there is a scene towards the end that gives me goosebumps everytime.dakota is sitting in the front seat with the father at the killers house before the dad goes in.dakota is sitting in shadow,conversing with the dad.her face is mostly in shadow,with one large,luminous eye visible,which catches the moonlight vividly.this scene is eerily similar to scene in 'roman holiday' where cary grant and audrey hepburn are sitting in the horse-drawn taxi,just before she goes back to her princess life.its the SAME scene,face heavily in shadow,one large eye,conveying emotion and turmoil.in dakotas case,she is near death,as she has trouble breathing,needs to find the killer,closure with her other half.it is even stated in the movie dialogue that she only feels like 'half a person'.this truly is a great movie,THE CRITICS AND HATERS BE DAMNED!!!!!!!!!!!!!! peace everybody,please go see it. cobaltduck,
an observation on my part;when dakota sleeps with aubreys boyfriend,jerrod,it is really aubrey wanting to have sex,or lose her virginity,before she passes on.aubrey and jerrod were not having sex in their relationship,as she was either a virgin,or not ready for sex in their dating.although aubrey is subtle in her flirting and sexiness,the film does not give any hint if she is a virgin or just cautious about sex.i believe that since aubrey is rather low-key and prim with regards to sex,dakota is a her wild side-an overtly sexual and dominant personality.this movie is full of pyschological details and hidden meanings and really makes you think.you have to see it more than once.i have seen it three times now,and i can say it was money well spent.also,i have to say that Lindsay did a remarkable job in establishing the two characters as entirely seperate personalities,from the physical to the behavioral.she truly is a great actress and compelling onscreen.there is a scene towards the end that gives me goosebumps everytime.dakota is sitting in the front seat with the father at the killers house before the dad goes in.dakota is sitting in shadow,conversing with the dad.her face is mostly in shadow,with one large,luminous eye visible,which catches the moonlight vividly.this scene is eerily similar to scene in ‘roman holiday’ where cary grant and audrey hepburn are sitting in the horse-drawn taxi,just before she goes back to her princess life.its the SAME scene,face heavily in shadow,one large eye,conveying emotion and turmoil.in dakotas case,she is near death,as she has trouble breathing,needs to find the killer,closure with her other half.it is even stated in the movie dialogue that she only feels like ‘half a person’.this truly is a great movie,THE CRITICS AND HATERS BE DAMNED!!!!!!!!!!!!!! peace
everybody,please go see it.

]]> By: Rachel Rule:dave must visit LG.com often http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-6732 Rachel Rule:dave must visit LG.com often Fri, 03 Aug 2007 07:05:10 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-6732 dan combs aka cobaltduck...i agree with most of your synopsis.i have a question.the old pickup truck,belonging to the gardener,is shown fully restored and gleaming in the driveway at the beginning.later,after aubrey flips off the gardener,the truck is shown beat up,dirty,a headlight hanging down,also like that,after the game,the night aubrey is kidnapped.what gives?peace dan combs aka cobaltduck…i agree with most of your synopsis.i have a question.the old pickup truck,belonging to the gardener,is shown fully restored and gleaming in the driveway at the beginning.later,after aubrey flips off the gardener,the truck is shown beat up,dirty,a headlight hanging down,also like that,after the game,the night aubrey is kidnapped.what gives?peace

]]> By: CobaltDuck http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-6900 CobaltDuck Fri, 03 Aug 2007 03:28:14 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-6900 People that don't understand the movie "I know who killed me" here *spoliers* I'll explain it to you. CobaltDuck explains - The Movie is not about a Twin finding her sister like some psychological mystery crime drama. ITs not really torture porn. Its a Psychological thriller. The movie a about Aubrey using her imagination to try to solve the mystery of who is killing her. Aubrey doesn't make it. Aubrey is killed. Aubrey is captured, tortured, buried alive, and the mysterious killer gets away with it. Aubrey doesn't know who is killing her, so she retreats to her mind and to avoid the pain and try to make sense out of why this is happening to her. That part where Dakota lays down next to Aubrey isn't a tired Dakota taking a quick nap its Aubrey finally dieing. The MOvie on the very first viewing is suppose to confuse you...it leads you in many directions and possibilities.. Does Aubrey has multiple personality disorder, or maybe she is an engineered twin for an experiment (take note of the similar faces of the 2 previous girls maybe they were both engineered twins and killed as well), or Dakota really is a twin... These are just decoy plots. Every time Dakota feels pain..thats not Dakota thats Aubrey feeling it. Every vision Dakota has is not a vision .thats Aubrey seeing the situation. The movie's first viewings purpose is to make you think the story is going in a different direction. Only at the very end does it become clear and the movie comes into focus. It should hit you in the gut that Aubrey didn't make it. Its sad. It should make you angry because Aubrey is strong and not weak but she never had a chance to fight back. The 2nd viewing you have the time to look at all the clues, because maybe the Piano teacher wasn't the one that killed her maybe thats just Aubrey's best guess before she died, its probabley the gardener. Maybe it was the strange man on the bus. Maybe its the psychiatrist. Maybe the killer is hidden in her mind. Maybe no clue in her mind will help her solve the mystery. Even Aubrey herself doesn't understand why she is doing this. I like to think Aubrey got it right and figured it out and gave her self some comfort for solving the mystery. People that criticise the movie, including newspaper critics, just don't get the point of the movie. It goes right over their head. They can't see it even though its right in front of their eyes. One could start to suspect where the movie was heading when the "strange" explanation for Dakota losing body parts was explained by "Twin stigmata". This is a fantasy, they could of equally used Voodoo or witchcraft or alien invaders as fantasy substitutes. Then when Dakota decided to drive with her father to the piano teachers house (with out back up or calling the police i might add) the direction of the story should of become suspect. When Dakota said "I think i know who killed me" the audience should of started figured it out, because why would Dakota say "I think i Know who killed me" it doesn't make sense, Dakota was never touched by the Piano teacher, nor was she being killed, she said it because she was Aubrey and Aubrey was close to death and wanted to figure it out. Then Dakota finds Aubrey... it should become obvious that all of this is in Aubreys head. Dakota joins Aubrey because Aubrey is in her last breath. The movie ends and goes no further because Aubrey is dead. If it wasn't in Aubreys head then the next scene would show the next day at her dads funeral with both sisters on crutches. But, Aubrey is dead. The movie isn't suppose to make you feel good. It should make you feel sad/angry/depressed/uncomfortable. It is not a normal happy Holloywood movie. But its tragedy will keep you thinking about it for a long time. the stripper scenes make you feel like the movie you see is real. If the ending was a happy ending the effect would not be the same. Aubrey dies... and its really sad and such a waste. I know who killed me is a good movie. CobaltDuck Dan Combs People that don’t understand the movie “I know who killed me” here *spoliers* I’ll explain it to you.

CobaltDuck explains – The Movie is not about a Twin finding her sister like some psychological mystery crime drama. ITs not really torture porn. Its a Psychological thriller. The movie a about Aubrey using her imagination to try to solve the mystery of who is killing her. Aubrey doesn’t make it. Aubrey is killed. Aubrey is captured, tortured, buried alive, and the mysterious killer gets away with it. Aubrey doesn’t know who is killing her, so she retreats to her mind and to avoid the pain and try to make sense out of why this is happening to her. That part where Dakota lays down next to Aubrey isn’t a tired Dakota taking a quick nap its Aubrey finally dieing.

The MOvie on the very first viewing is suppose to confuse you…it leads you in many directions and possibilities.. Does Aubrey has multiple personality disorder, or maybe she is an engineered twin for an experiment (take note of the similar faces of the 2 previous girls maybe they were both engineered twins and killed as well), or Dakota really is a twin… These are just decoy plots. Every time Dakota feels pain..thats not Dakota thats Aubrey feeling it. Every vision Dakota has is not a vision .thats Aubrey seeing the situation. The movie’s first viewings purpose is to make you think the story is going in a different direction. Only at the very end does it become clear and the movie comes into focus. It should hit you in the gut that Aubrey didn’t make it. Its sad. It should make you angry because Aubrey is strong and not weak but she never had a chance to fight back.

The 2nd viewing you have the time to look at all the clues, because maybe the Piano teacher wasn’t the one that killed her maybe thats just Aubrey’s best guess before she died, its probabley the gardener. Maybe it was the strange man on the bus. Maybe its the psychiatrist. Maybe the killer is hidden in her mind. Maybe no clue in her mind will help her solve the mystery. Even Aubrey herself doesn’t understand why she is doing this. I like to think Aubrey got it right and figured it out and gave her self some comfort for solving the mystery.

People that criticise the movie, including newspaper critics, just don’t get the point of the movie. It goes right over their head. They can’t see it even though its right in front of their eyes. One could start to suspect where the movie was heading when the “strange” explanation for Dakota losing body parts was explained by “Twin stigmata”. This is a fantasy, they could of equally used Voodoo or witchcraft or alien invaders as fantasy substitutes. Then when Dakota decided to drive with her father to the piano teachers house (with out back up or calling the police i might add) the direction of the story should of become suspect. When Dakota said “I think i know who killed me” the audience should of started figured it out, because why would Dakota say “I think i Know who killed me” it doesn’t make sense, Dakota was never touched by the Piano teacher, nor was she being killed, she said it because she was Aubrey and Aubrey was close to death and wanted to figure it out. Then Dakota finds Aubrey… it should become obvious that all of this is in Aubreys head. Dakota joins Aubrey because Aubrey is in her last breath. The movie ends and goes no further because Aubrey is dead. If it wasn’t in Aubreys head then the next scene would show the next day at her dads funeral with both sisters on crutches. But, Aubrey is dead.

The movie isn’t suppose to make you feel good. It should make you feel sad/angry/depressed/uncomfortable. It is not a normal happy Holloywood movie. But its tragedy will keep you thinking about it for a long time. the stripper scenes make you feel like the movie you see is real. If the ending was a happy ending the effect would not be the same. Aubrey dies… and its really sad and such a waste.

I know who killed me is a good movie.

CobaltDuck

Dan Combs

]]> By: lola http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/comment-page-1/#comment-6901 lola Fri, 03 Aug 2007 01:08:35 +0000 http://www.lohangroupie.com/i-know-who-killed-me-reviews/#comment-6901 i have not seen this moive! but i hope its good.....atlest not as bad as they say. lol love you linds i have not seen this moive! but i hope its good…..atlest not as bad as they say.

lol love you linds

]]>